What happened?! After coming off last week's unfortunate flu outbreak, which left me bed-ridden for the better part of five days, I was about to start posting vol. 1 of
me vs ashtar when out of the blue, Samir, of all people decides to get into heated debate with me over the movies I watch. Here's what transpired (Editing is kept to a minimum. Stuff in parenthesis is my commentary upon reviewing the conversation, so feel free Samir, to post your own later):
Samir(tar): have u seen i, robot?
Ic3man: no. cant say i really want to either
Samir(tar): That's tony pane for ya. Claims he has a "open mind", but really doesn't. You have to admit, open mind means trying new things, which u don't do much. Anyways, i thought it was interesting but didn't like the end.

(ummmm.... does having an open mind mean I have watch to watch every average to below average summer action movie starring Will Smith??? Secondly ... trying new things......are you joking. How many more movies do I have to watch than all my roommates combined before I am trying new things?? I am pretty sure that bewteen Samir and I, I am the only one whos seen a movie made before 1975.)
Ic3man: Cant say i find i,robot to be all that appealing. 1.concept isnt original. 2. is an insult to the book its based off of 3. stars will smith. Ic3man: I still have to have an interest in going to see a movie, regardless of having an open mind. I am not going to waste 2 and a half hours of my life with a movie that has no appeal to me.
Samir(tar): You need to get out of reading reviews and experience stuff for urself
Ic3man: Right....im just supposed to watch
everything that comes out of hollywood... when i go to research a movie i usually take about 100 critics opinions together (rottentomatoes) and try to form some kind of conclusion as to whether a movie might be worth 2 hours of my life
Samir(tar): Yeah, wasting 2 hours reading about it rather than seeing it
Ic3man: 2 hours, ha. More like 10min on the database. I read the synopsis and maybe some opinions. Maybe watch the trailer.
Samir(tar): But i still think even though u do save time, by not "wasting it" ur missing out, on the good movies....which are worth seeing, and which u don't know anything about going in. I have 90% no idea going into a movie what to expect. Sure then the movie sucks, i'll admit i wasted my life, but when it's good, it's awesome. You on the other hand might not know 10% of the movie or what is to come. I agree in doing research for something I'm about to go spend my money on, like cars, shoes, games, and all that. but movies... not so much. If i like the trailer or idea i'll go see it.
(Knowing 90% going in is quite the exaggeration... that is, unless the movie has no plot to speak of... and then I am probably right in not going to see it. Secondly, Samir says that he would do research on a variety of things he spends money on.... with the exception of movies...this make sense to anybody?)
Ic3man: Usually if im not interested in a movie initially someone will have had to recommend a movie to me for me to watch it. If im not interested initally, it takes the good opinions and recommendations of people i trust for me to get up and watch it. I mean if im not interested and i havent heard peple give pos. feedback who've seen it (whom I trust) then i probabaly wont take a look. thats bascially the case with i, Robot.
(By the way, just because a movie gets positive feedback does not necessarily mean I want to see it or am going to see it OR think that it is good myself. For instance,
I, Robot got a Fresh rating from rottentomatoes.com (61%), but that does not mean I care. Or in the case of the 'classic' Hitchcock movie,
The Birds, which I personally found to be disappointing, most, if not all critics will tell you its a masterpiece. On a side note, I wonder how many Hitchcock movies Samir has seen? Maybe we should compare movie libraries or movie knowledge to see who's been trying new (and old) things?)
Samir(tar): Ex. war of the worlds, i didn't know what to expect, but aliens...hmm, like the idea, i'll go see it, but then it sucked for me...i made my own opinion. Yeah, for u i guess, u must know what happens and how it happens.
Ic3man: Well, thats cause i read the book.
Samir(tar): You probably knew how the aliens came down before seeing it -> because of the synopsis.
Ic3man: Right, that will want to make someone want to go too. The concept. t\The synopsis, which i look at, like i said before.
Samir(tar): Synopis for me (my opinion) if it's like a page...long, that's a little too much. I create my own concepts in my head from a trailer.
(I just hope he's not buying too much into the commercialism....)
Samir(tar): Details. In other movies, then, what a normal person from just seeing the trailer wouldn't know - you might know more which may ruin or lessen the effect of the movie overall
S Agent AP: I tend to disagree there. Yeh, so i try to inform myself a little before viewing a flick. I never had a good movie spoiled by a little investigation. I'm not talking about major plot points, just a good overview. A good movie will (and should) stand on its own, regardless of what I know going in or how many times I have seen it.
Samir(tar): haha...tony...have u tried seeing a good movie without knowing....then u'll have a BETTER experience.
S Agent AP: sure , lots of movies ive seen without previous knowledge going in(the rock, seven, and pulp fiction just to name a few good ones). But in the end, a good movie is a good movie regardless of what i do or dont know about it going in.
(He has a point here - obviously if I had known the ending to
Seven I might not have loved the movie as much. But I'm not talking about knowing key plot points as I have already discussed. All I am saying is that its good to get an idea of what a movie is about and a few opinions before plopping down 10 bucks and reserving 2 hours of one's life for it.)
**Note: I was watching Memento while trying to carry out this conversation.
Please post your comments. Your opinions will help make this column better.....maybe.